The trouble with SREC’s
Thursday, July 1st, 2010Time and again, we hear about a new “solar project” in the works. The plans for these large-scale installations are always quite grand and include the promise of profits in the near term. However, more often than not we don’t see projects coming to fruitarian. For some reason, great projects are not growing the wings they need to get off the ground. Obviously, it all comes down to money.
Consider the finances of a solar project. Per kW installed cost, federal tax credits and state incentives are fairly similar across the board. In terms of income, we have the value of generated electricity, which is usually chump change compared to the big hitter… SRECs. Yes, the government’s answer to the age old question “How do we make them comply?” For those of you unfamiliar, there are hundreds of websites, but generally speaking, Solar Renewable Energy Credits (SRECs) are credits generated for every MW-hr of photovoltaic derived energy. The owner of the panels owns the credits and is free to sell them. Buyers of credits are the large electricity generators (PECO, PennPower, Edison, etc.) The generators will buy credits to make up for any shortfalls they have in meeting the state mandated renewable energy standard.
Now lets get back to SRECs. How much are they worth? Well, it depends where you live. Check out the table below for June 2010 prices:
| State | SREC Trading Price |
| Washington DC | $290.00 |
| Delaware | $300.00 |
| Maryland | $326.50 |
| New Jersey | $665.00 |
| Ohio | $325.00 |
| Pennsylvania | $310.00 |
Prices for SRECs vary from state to state ($290 to $665). Between states that all trading of SCRECs across state lines, the prices are more normalized, however, the driving forces for the markets are still ambiguous. That’s another word for unpredictable or volatile. Two words that investors don’t like to hear. Of course the laws of supply and demand come into play here, however there is no means of predicting where prices will go. So, if you were an investor and the return on your investment was based on a volatile and unpredictable commodity would you feel safe investing your money? Is investment in solar projects the equivalent of visiting the tables in Vegas or AC?
So, although the state regulators had good intentions with the renewable energy portfolios, incentives for projects and mandated penalties for non-compliance, the plan had a huge hole. Since SREC prices can not be counted on, the driving forces thrusting us into the age of renewable energy have sputtered. Is there a solution? Of course… 1) Renewable Energy Portfolio standards need to be nationalized; 2) A “bottom price” needs to be placed on SREC prices. By nationalizing the programs, the disparity between neighboring states will be normalized. Meanwhile a bottom price will reduce a portion of the risk associated with investment in solar projects. If governments are really serious about energy independence and investing in the green future, they too will soon see the shortfalls in the current system. Lets hope for change.
Sandip D. Shah, Ph.D.
The Amish way of life has learned to live side by side with secular residents in Lancaster County for years, despite differences in the way the two cultures choose to live. But while Lancaster’s newest proposed addition will involve electricity, it shouldn’t ruffle too many Mennonite beards as this improvement is both respectful to the environment and completely silent.
As Solar States founder Micah Gold-Markel continues the fight to bring solar energy to Philadelphia, Solar States is bringing some new voices to the conversation. This month, Solar States is hosting monthly investor salons to talk to alternative energy investors and venture capitalists about the state of the alternative energy marketplace and what it will take to make the solar dream a reality in Philadelphia.
Solar States is at it again! With students at the 


